Hey,
A couple of weeks ago, I ran a workshop for around 25 people.
One of the activities involved building a tower, balancing a tennis ball on top, and keeping the whole thing standing for 20 seconds.
Simple enough, right?
Well, there were a few twists.
Every team had different materials, they were working against the clock, and they could ask other teams for help.
As you can imagine, things got interesting pretty quickly π€
But what fascinated me wasn't the towers.
It was how incredibly NICE everyone was to each other.
Some teams desperately needed materials that others had, but nobody wanted to risk asking for help in case they got rejected.
People watched their teammates pursue ideas that clearly weren't working, but didn't want to challenge them.
Everyone was so determined to be considerate that they were making the challenge harder for themselves.
During the debrief, I asked how they'd handled conflict.
Someone was very quick to reassure me:
"Oh no, there was no conflict at all!"
As though I'd just accused them of starting a bar fight π
And I thought, well, there's something interesting to unpack here.
The peculiar problem with being too nice
I see this quite often when working with teams.
Everyone gets along well enough. People are considerate, respectful, keen to maintain good relationships.
All lovely things, of course.
But somewhere along the way, we started equating disagreement with disapproval. And we started taking conflict personally.
So we avoid the awkward conversations.
So we let an idea go unchallenged because someone's clearly very excited about it.
We watch a colleague struggle because we don't want to interfere.
We agree to things we're not entirely convinced by because, well, it's easier than making things uncomfortable.
And sometimes, by trying so hard to be nice, we're actually doing each other a disservice.
I know I'd much rather someone tell me my idea is terrible while I can still do something about it than smile politely and let me spend three months finding out for myself.
Of course, nobody wants to work with someone who challenges absolutely everything. That sounds exhausting.
But I wonder whether we've become so worried about creating tension that we've forgotten how useful a little healthy disagreement can be?
Especially when everyone's trying to achieve the same thing.
Your one bold move:
Invite *genuinely* constructive criticism
Next time your team is discussing a proposal, instead of asking:
"Does everyone agree?"
Try asking:
"What would make this idea even better?"
It's a gentler invitation to question something, without making people feel like they're picking holes in a colleague's work.
And you might be surprised by what comes up when people feel invited to build on an idea rather than simply approve it.
Because sometimes the nicest thing you can do for someone is tell them their tower's about to fall over.
Preferably before theyβve spent all their allocated time building it.
Happy experimenting!
Amale
Whenever you're ready, here's how we can work together:
π Want more ideas to put into practice? Grab a copy of Experimental, my bestselling book on building high-performing, change-ready teams. Get the book β
π€ Want to bring this thinking to your next event? Book me to speak about leadership, change and innovation. Explore my keynotes β
π₯ Want to transform how your team works together? Bring in The Brick Coach for hands-on workshops and programmes that help your people make change happen. Explore our experiences β